We have looked into carob chocolate before, we know of many people who give it to their dogs. It smells and tastes a lot like chocolate but it isn't chocolate or harmful to dogs at all. One thing we read prevented us from using carob chocolate for Caeda. Someone said (on a forum that I can't recall, and I hope I can explain it properly), that if you feed your dog the chocolate, they will associate the smell and taste with being "dog treat", if your dog ever goes anywhere near REAL chocolate, you wouldn't want them to think it is a dog food....so its better to associate the taste and smell of all chocolate with "NO" rather than with "Good Dog". I hope that makes sense....