Dog Forum banner

Teaching the dog that doesn’t learn?

2.3K views 13 replies 7 participants last post by  Singh  
#1 ·
Hi everyone. Story time, I guess! Bare with me if you can.

I have a 1 year old female St Bernard names Mocha. I’ve had her since she was 8 weeks old and she was 9 pounds then, she’s 105 now.

When she was a puppy, she had pretty much nailed “sit”, “shake”, “roll over” and “lay down”. BUT she only knows the hand signals, not the words. So if she’s not 100% focused on me she doesn’t listen, or in this case, see what I’m asking. I always paired the word with the hand signal but she just never caught on. After that I haven’t been able to teach her ANYTHING.

I would love to say it’s just her being “stubborn”. But I can’t, because she doesn’t know anything. Not even her name, or fun words like “walk” “peanut butter” “treat” “Let’s go out” “good girl” etc. Nothing. She barely ever responds when your trying to catch her attention. The only way she looks at you is if you talk in a ridiculously high pitched voice, pretty much screaming. Sigh. I seriously thought she was completely, or at least mostly, deaf for months. But when I got her spayed I had the vet check her hearing and apparently it was perfect.

I’m at loss here. Mocha is the sweetest thing, adores people and every animal she meets, but she doesn’t learn. I tried treating her everytime I said her name with no improvement. I still had to wave my hand in front of her face to get her to look at me. Trying to teach her to recall is pointless, even on a leash I literally have to pull her all the way to me after say “come here!” no matter how many times I do it, or how delicious or exciting the reward is.

How do I teach a dog that’s unteachable? I’m so ready to give up. It’s been months and she hasn’t learned a single word, much less a vocal cue for anything. I use positive reinforcement, keep sessions short and exciting, use very high value rewards, set her up so it’s nearly impossible to fail, but she doesn’t learn.

Any advice? Tips? She’s too big to not be trained...
 
#2 ·
If she is only paying attention to loud noises/high pitched sounds or shouts, and hand signals, I would suspect she does have hearing difficulties.
Can she hear food related sounds - a kibble dropped in a bowl, a treat bag rattle, sounds that most dogs would pay close attention to?

Wouldn't hurt to get her hearing rechecked by your vet, or even a second opinion from another vet.
 
#6 ·
If she is only paying attention to loud noises/high pitched sounds or shouts, and hand signals, I would suspect she does have hearing difficulties.
Can she hear food related sounds - a kibble dropped in a bowl, a treat bag rattle, sounds that most dogs would pay close attention to?

Wouldn't hurt to get her hearing rechecked by your vet, or even a second opinion from another vet.
Sometimes? When she sees me with her food dish she comes to check it out, but doesn’t come when I’m filling it. It’s stainless steel so pretty loud. Treat bags are usually a no, unless she sees it. She mostly copies the other dogs reactions, and if there aren’t any other dogs she doesn’t seem to notice as much.

The one sound she ALWAYS reacts to is me dropping my heavy boots on the floor because it means I’m going out with the horses. The (very creaky) door is hit or miss.
 
#5 ·
Third that this dog is at least partially, if not fully, deaf. Get that second opinion, really . I had a coworker that is largely partially deaf from childhood that the doctor initially said had "perfectly fine" hearing. I. the meantime, treat her as if she is fully deaf. Facebook has a few great groups for this, and work on introducing some body touch pairings with those hand signals.
 
#14 ·
Most likely needs a second opinion regarding her hearing. You have tried using the high pitch talk which works so gradually try and tone it down each time rewarding her. She may have learnt that she can ignore you till you scream…