Dog Forum banner

Should I rehome? Really struggling.

2.4K views 8 replies 4 participants last post by  Curls  
#1 · (Edited)
A month ago my DH and I went to a rescue's puppy event after thinking about adding a dog into our family for many months. We weren't certain that this was the best time but the rescue lady encouraged us to just come down and see the puppies (first mistake). When we got there she had a couple of typical rescue dogs (older pitties etc) and then suddenly a number of adorable puppies of various breeds (including desirable ones like Shih Tzus and Dachshunds!) My instincts were SCREAMING at me to leave but we saw one tiny poodle mix puppy alone in a cardboard box under the table and DH and I looked at each other and said 'we can't leave him here". So we paid the 'rescue' for the puppy and took him home.

From the day he arrived I started having massive panic attacks. I have PTSD and anxiety disorder but both were under control before this tiny furry bomb went off in our lives. Despite all the reading we'd done nothing prepared us for the sleeplessness, the crying, the neediness, the potty accidents... it was HUGELY overwhelming. My three kids obviously loved the little boy immediately (but the child we had most hoped would bond with him, our neurodivergent child whose doctor suggested we get a dog to help with his anxiety, showed little interest). I have struggled with the lack of ability to do anything, take my kids for an ice cream after school etc... I know these things are temporary but in my current state I can't see the light at the end of the tunnel. I also suffer with an autoimmune condition and I'm feeling totally exhausted and in a 'flare' due to lack of sleep.

I have been so stressed I've barely eaten (and lost 5KG). I haven't slept at all in the month that we've had this little boy, even though his night sleeps are much better now. After the first couple of weeks I accepted that I was deep in the 'puppy blues' and spent lots of time with the pup, playing and loving on him. I am 100% his 'person', he tolerates the kids sometimes but growls at them quite often, he is MUCH happier when they are in school. My kids are fighting ALL the time at the moment and I'm on edge from this, too.

In recent days my DH's company announced a round of redundancies. He hasn't been impacted (yet) but his already huge workload has increased. We both WFH and I had assumed I could leave the pup with him when I was out with the kids/running errands etc but he has told me he has no bandwidth to add anything else to his plate. He's not being selfish, he's hugely stressed and I am honestly concerned about his mental wellbeing, too. I had to take the pup to a local dogsitter today as he cannot be left even for five minutes, if I'm out of sight he cries and cries and honestly I am struggling with the feeling of being trapped. I never even let my human kids 'cry it out' (as some dog owners have suggested I do) so I couldn't do it with the pup, either. I accept that he is too young to be left alone for more than a few minutes but as he is really a companion breed I worry that separation anxiety goes with the territory. We have no family in this country, and a very small support network. A friend who had previously promised to occasionally help with the pup has changed her mind, she has a lot going on with her kids and she doesn't have time now. Any help we get will have to be paid for, and with a puppy this young I worry about this being disruptive for him. Again, I have anxiety so I do catastrophize and worry about everything. On top of all of the above, my husband suffered a family bereavement and we have to go overseas to deal with the affairs (pup would be 6 months old when this happens). We will be gone for 3-4 weeks and would have to leave him with a dogsitter, again I worry about how this will affect him? We also have a home move happening fairly imminently as our landlord just told us of his intentions to sell.

So my dilemma is this. I LOVE this little boy with all my heart. My kids love him, even though they do nothing to help wuth his care (and their schedules are only getting busier). Two days ago a friend mentioned my situation to someone she knows and she asked if she could come and meet the pup. She's a retired lady who lives with another retired woman, and their small poodle mix was recently PTS. She came and sat on the floor and my pup wagged his tail like crazy and jumped all over her like she was his best friend in the world. She cried and said she'd fallen in love. She is home all day, every day, and has a big house with a flat yard. She brought him a toy that he immediately loved and when I left the room for a minute he didn't whine or cry or follow me (this is honestly a first). I was shocked at how quickly he bonded with her.
The lady said she would love to adopt him, and as she lives close she said she would let me and the kids visit whenever we wanted. I said I needed a few days to think about it and since then, my anxiety has been out of control. I'm barely functioning. The thought of handing over my sweet baby fills me with despair BUT my husband said the dog would be leaving us for a major life upgrade (that's a hard thing to hear but it's true). I worry that I'll be filled with regret and will never forgive myself if we give him to this lovely lady, but I also worry that the puppy phase might push my family over the edge with all we have going on right now. I can't think rationally during this spiral (I'm waiting to see my doctor but even new meds will take weeks to take effect and I can't let the dog get more bonded to us, and this lady might get a breeder dog instead if we take too long to decide). My kids will be very sad to see him go, and this also breaks my heart. We have fostered cats in the past, though, for a similar amount of time so I hope they'd see it as a similar situation: loving and socializing an animal until you find its forever home.

What should I do? Power through and hope that this is just puppy blues, pay for as much help as I can get until it gets more manageable? Or let my beautiful boy go to the best home he could ever dream of? I'm crying my eyes out just typing this, and if you want to tell me I'm a terrible person please don't, I already feel like the worst person on earth.
 
#2 ·
I read your whole post, and want you to know that I very much sympathize with you. You are not in any way a terrible person, at least not from what you are saying and not because you are thinking of rehoming this puppy. In fact, what I think you are is a brave and tried and overwhelmed and very caring person who wants very much to do the right thing and the best thing for the dog. No more than that could be asked of you.

Since you want opinions, I will give mine, which is that I think you should rehome the dog. It is in the dog's best interests, the dog will have a great home with someone who wants him and is fully prepared to give him a good home. It will hurt at first, but my guess is it will feel also like a great relief, because you will know you did the right thing. The dog will be happy and you will have less stress. It's a win for everyone.

If you were dedicated and certain you wanted to keep the dog, we could help a lot with training advice. But that is not what I am reading here at all. Let the dog go, and do not feel bad about it.

I think that sometimes an animal comes to one person just so that they can get to the person they are really supposed to be with. I think this is the case here, because that pup and his potential new person wouldn't have met without you. Feel good about that!
 
#3 ·
Thank you so much for this, your words have made me cry even more. I suppose my huge worry is regret: what if we'd just persevered? What if the dog DIDN'T end up with bad separation anxiety (that's my big fear)? What if I break my kids' hearts? It's SO hard to know what to do as he is very very loved and happy with us, but I know he would be cherished and adored with this other woman, too, and she has much more time to devote to him. Truly, I'm heartbroken.
 
#4 ·
I too read every word of your posts, and I agree with @Madra Anamchara. This isn't a good time for your family to be adding a dog, and the potential is there for it to get more stressful, not less. The lady who met the puppy sounds ideal. Check her out a little so you become even more comfortable with the rehoming. Visit her home, meet the other woman she lives with. Talk more to your friend who sent this person to you, etc. If all that looks good, in your shoes I'd go ahead and rehome and be happy to have found such a good situation for a puppy you want the best for.
 
#6 ·
Thank you for your kind words. I told my kids that we had found a wonderful home for the pup and while my two older children took it quite well my youngest sobbed herself to sleep, and woke up this morning crying again. She is obsessed with dogs and has wanted one for years so now I am sobbing again, thinking I need to 'woman up' and make this work for my child, and feeling like the worst human who ever lived.
 
#5 ·
Being heartbroken is understandable. I have fostered many dogs and letting some of them go broke my heart at the time. But there is no regret, and I sincerely doubt that you will feel regret either.

The most important thing here in my opinion is the best interests of the dog. I know you and your family love the dog, but love is not always enough. Right now you are not in a position to give this dog the best home; the other woman is. And best of all, you don't have to give the dog away and never see him again.....you will be able to visit and see how happy the dog is. If the dog is happy and well cared for there's nothing to regret, ever!

The kids will get to visit the dog as well, and it is a good thing for them to learn that sometimes you really need to put the best interests of the animal ahead of what you want. I had to learn that as a kid, and it hurt at the time. But it was one of the most important lessons I ever learned in my early life, allowing me to have far better and more selfless relationships with the animals that have been in my life ever since. Trust me, you won't be doing your kids any disservice to let them learn this.

I actually think you are more likely to regret it if you do not let the dog go to this new home.
 
#7 ·
Being heartbroken is understandable. I have fostered many dogs and letting some of them go broke my heart at the time. But there is no regret, and I sincerely doubt that you will feel regret either.

The most important thing here in my opinion is the best interests of the dog. I know you and your family love the dog, but love is not always enough. Right now you are not in a position to give this dog the best home; the other woman is. And best of all, you don't have to give the dog away and never see him again.....you will be able to visit and see how happy the dog is. If the dog is happy and well cared for there's nothing to regret, ever!

The kids will get to visit the dog as well, and it is a good thing for them to learn that sometimes you really need to put the best interests of the animal ahead of what you want. I had to learn that as a kid, and it hurt at the time. But it was one of the most important lessons I ever learned in my early life, allowing me to have far better and more selfless relationships with the animals that have been in my life ever since. Trust me, you won't be doing your kids any disservice to let them learn this.

I actually think you are more likely to regret it if you do not let the dog go to this new home.
I too read every word of your posts, and I agree with @Madra Anamchara. This isn't a good time for your family to be adding a dog, and the potential is there for it to get more stressful, not less. The lady who met the puppy sounds ideal. Check her out a little so you become even more comfortable with the rehoming. Visit her home, meet the other woman she lives with. Talk more to your friend who sent this person to you, etc. If all that looks good, in your shoes I'd go ahead and rehome and be happy to have found such a good situation for a puppy you want the best for.

Thank you for your kind words. I told my kids that we had found a wonderful home for the pup and while my two older children took it quite well my youngest sobbed herself to sleep, and woke up this morning crying again. She is obsessed with dogs and has wanted one for years so now I am sobbing again, thinking I need to 'woman up' and make this work for my child, and feeling like the worst human who ever lived.
 
#8 ·
Your child will get over this.
You have made an adult decision. Stick to it. And stop feeling guilty.
You weighed all the various factors, you asked for advice and got some, and you gave it consideration. Now, you need to stick to the decision you made and make it stand.

Your young child will not learn any good lessons in life if crying will get her to change your mind when you have made a well thought out and rational decision. It will not be doing her any favors for you to let her manipulate you. And you won't be doing yourself any favors either.

To try to "make this work for my child" would be a mistake in my opinion.

Tell your child that when the time is right, you will get a dog who stays. Then she has something to look forward to. And in the meantime, she can work something out with the new owner of the dog to come and visit the dog, maybe even take the dog for walks.

You have absolutely nothing to feel bad about. sometimes things work out and sometimes they don't, and it is rarely anyone's "fault".
 
#9 ·
You have very good reasons for rehoming the dog. I think one of the most difficult lessons for any person, let alone a child, is that sometimes love isn't enough to make a relationship work. Sometimes the other person (or puppy) has needs that you simply cannot satisfy. It sounds like your family has a lot going on: the memorial trip, the move, your husband's job situation. That means, however much you love the puppy, your family is not able to provide the care and stability the puppy needs and deserves at this stage in its life. Letting go of someone (or something) you love is hard, but sometimes it's the best thing.