Dog Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
21 - 40 of 47 Posts

· Banned
Joined
·
267 Posts
I don't require you to go around, but a simple "Hey!" would have had me realize someone was behind me and we would have moved to increase Tessa's threshold. What if I was deaf?
Good question. What if you were deaf? What would you expect the runner to do then? Yelling "Hey!" sure isn't going to work.
And you don't have to be deaf. A lot of people listen to music when they walk or run. If you'd had earbuds in listening to music with your hood up, no verbal warning would've reached you even if he'd given one.

It seems to me that the dog may not be the only one in this partnership who is reactive and fear aggressive.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
568 Posts
Good question. What if you were deaf? What would you expect the runner to do then? Yelling "Hey!" sure isn't going to work.
And you don't have to be deaf. A lot of people listen to music when they walk or run. If you'd had earbuds in listening to music with your hood up, no verbal warning would've reached you even if he'd given one.

It seems to me that the dog may not be the only one in this partnership who is reactive and fear aggressive.


I'm not the one this is asking but being hearing impared I can answer this.


Most people make enough noise to at least alert the dog that I walk with and then Manna alerts me like she has been trained to do.

On occasion (way more often than I like)
A runner or someone on a bike races up behind and Manna either doesn't hear them or can't alert me in time. These people also are usually the ones who won't move from dead center of the sidewalk (I walk on the far right to give more room to passing people on the left ) and come within and often touch /brush against me and Manna.
I've been knocked off of side walks because of these people.

I can only assume that op experienced something similar and felt the need to express their frustration.

I yell and curse the people in the moment. And yeah it's a problem.
I don't like being driven and knocked off the sidewalk, I can get hurt easily this way.

People often just don't think about how their sidewalk hogging affects others or just don't care.

It's not that hard to slow down slightly and move to the left of the paved area.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,826 Posts
Yeah I know the op intentionally tries to walk in less populated areas and be strategic so she'd less likely to encounter things that will trigger her dog. Of course if a bite does happen then the owner is still to blame no matter what. I have a dog I never wal because of reactivity. I'm very doubtful she'd ever bite anybody. But she's a big gsd. I don't need people being frightened by her.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,033 Posts
People often just don't think about how their sidewalk hogging affects others or just don't care.
It doesn't sound to me like the person in the OP was hogging the sidewalk? Just came up from behind and startled the OP's dog.

And I get it that it was frustrating and anxiety-provoking. But I think with a reactive dog there is an extra burden of being hyper-aware of your surroundings (I say this as the owner of two leash reactive dogs). Is it fair? No. But I don't think it's fair to place all of the blame on the runner, either.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
Discussion Starter · #25 ·
Since no one is letting this thread die off, I'll respond to a few things.
First:
Good question. What if you were deaf? What would you expect the runner to do then? Yelling "Hey!" sure isn't going to work.
And you don't have to be deaf. A lot of people listen to music when they walk or run. If you'd had earbuds in listening to music with your hood up, no verbal warning would've reached you even if he'd given one.
As @Flaming said, even the slightest sound would make most dogs note you're there; knowing a lot of people who use their dogs as service animals I can say most are intone with even the slightest head tilt which would prompt a human response. But even runners slowing down would be nice.

I also wanted to add to that post, but it was too late, about what if I had a toddler that ran out and tangled the runner and his dog? or was afraid of large dogs? just slowing down, making a sound, or moving a little (the sidewalk is rather wide) would prevent anyone from getting hurt.

It seems to me that the dog may not be the only one in this partnership who is reactive and fear aggressive.
I agree. I am a reactive and if I was a dog, I would definitely say a little fear aggressive, though I doubt I'll ever bite anyone - but who knows:D. Maybe I should wear a muzzle lol.

Me and Tessa are very similar. Every day I do my best to prevent my own anxiety to bounce off of hers, and vice versa. We use each other's experience to work through. It's my own experience that allows me to understand what she must be feeling. Some people wouldn't have this unique understanding, sometimes it's a blessing, sometimes a curse.

Also yeah, if my dog tried to bite someone BECAUSE he was reactive I would certainly muzzle him in public. It's not cruel, its for others safety. I may not be able to predict others' actions. Children run up to Cosmo all the time, if he was bite reactive I certainly would't want the liability of him biting a child. It sounds like your dog bites when approached quickly, I'd be concerned about that.
Again she didn't try to bite anyone, her mouth never even opened, she did move toward the danger though, which we are working on a better response to move away instead. Also any dog can bite when startled, whether it be at a vet clinic, out on a walk, startled from sleeping, fast moving objects, Old dogs that have lost eye sight or hearing, etc. Should all dogs be muzzled? I'm not trying to sound angry or aggressive, but it is a good debate, maybe one for another thread. What about a sheltie that nips at a bike rider riding by? Or a heeler who attempts to herd passing children? Should they require muzzling too? Even though they are doing something that can be trained to be inhibited. Just a thought I've had.

As I said, I doubt Tessa would ever bite anyone but at the time I made this thread I was still running off of adrenaline and anxiety so I had a lot of "what ifs" running through my mind and the thread reflects this. I wish I never posted - lesson learned. I definitely sounded more dramatic in those few moments of posting and I regret that, I had had rough day, this incident occurred, and well I vented. And yes at the time I felt I was allowed to hate on the person who was also involved in making me feel this way - we all do it, but I don't truly wish him ill, I just hated that whole situtation. My bad, but please stop telling me I need to be more attentive and muzzle my dog.

As I've repeated, if I felt it was required I would. It is at this time that both the trainer we are working with and I feel that a muzzle is not required. She was startled, as was I. If ever I feel she is a danger to bite I will definitely muzzle her, I have no issues with muzzling when warranted, but it's been agreed with the people who have met and assessed my dog that it is not needed.

I have, however, taken the whole experience and applied it to training with Tessa. She is learning a default "side". I understand not every situation is possible to expect, but we will be as ready as possible.

and yes @TiggerBounce is correct, I do my general walking at odd hours or in places most people don't take their dogs. We do small, short, training at parks where there are people and other dogs, but we are always at a distance Tessa feels comfortable. She has done amazing in improvement since her first moment of reactivity, almost 2 years ago. She can now meet strange people and let them pet her, she also can walk down the same side walk as a strange dog - barring this one incident, I am proud of my dog's progress.

Can we get over it now and let this vent rest in peace? Please?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,004 Posts
Sorry, I know you want the thread to die but I just wanted to chime in with some support.

Unless you were walking on a narrow sidewalk with a steep dropoff on each side, common courtesy would have been for the runner to move over and give you space *especially* as you both had dogs. He didn't have to cross the street, but moving over to give you a wide berth would have been polite. I do think he was rude - at least ignorant.

Whether or not your dog wears a muzzle is your call. If you don't put your dog in positions where she could bite and aren't constantly afraid she will, it could do more harm than good as if she wears one you could end up with a lot of negative attention. As you say, any dog could bite.

I think it's clear you are very good with your dog and have accomplished a lot with her. Sometimes it helps to vent!! I also have anxiety AND a reactive dog, so I've been there!

Just remember, each time you'll be a little stronger. You're learning and accomplishing more from your experiences than a random bystander with no reactive dog experience.

Hugs.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,661 Posts
100% agree with @PoppyKenna. I was a little confused with some of the responses.. I've always thought it was common sense/courtesy to give pedestrians a wide birth or warning when coming from behind regardless if they have a dog. I know not all people are going to do this, but that doesn't mean it's okay..

My dog can be motion reactive, so if someone decides to whiz by, there's a chance he might react (ie bark and lunge with the intention of chasing not biting). It's part of his herding instinct and there's no way I'm going to muzzle him for that.. From what I'be read , it sounds like Tessa reacted similarly.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,826 Posts
100% agree with @PoppyKenna. I was a little confused with some of the responses.. I've always thought it was common sense/courtesy to give pedestrians a wide birth or warning when coming from behind regardless if they have a dog. I know not all people are going to do this, but that doesn't mean it's okay..

My dog can be motion reactive, so if someone decides to whiz by, there's a chance he might react (ie bark and lunge with the intention of chasing not biting). It's part of his herding instinct and there's no way I'm going to muzzle him for that.. From what I'be read , it sounds like Tessa reacted similarly.
This is all just so crazy to me because that is so NORMAL here LOL. I've never thought of it as rude or anything like that. It's a public sidewalk. Oh well. I guess it's at least a heads up to know that you can't always expect people to give wide births or warnings from behind. I know some of the places where I've taken Tigger, there's no way a reactive dog could handle it. People automatically expect your dog to be perfectly fine...You brought it in public, so they assume it's not going to react or bite or lunge at them. If it does, then you get dirty looks from everybody.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,004 Posts
Every now and then there's a biker that will blow past, but I guess I just live in a kinder area? Even if it's just me, no dogs, I expect to be given some space when someone goes past me, especially if they're running/biking/roller blading/etc. I honestly can't imagine someone running past so close to me.

But, I guess we all have different experiences and could hash it out all day. Even if you expect dogs to behave in public, I still think the guy was rude and I understand the reaction to him.
 

· Banned
Joined
·
5,937 Posts
i can understand where @KayWilson is coming from and i just have to say something i agree with her about common courtesy because i know peope in public dont know this but i have no side vision and my walking is really odd so i go like side to side. I often dont see people till too late or really close up as im short sighted too.

To the general public they prob think i'm being rude but i do my best to apologise. I can totally relate to her anxiety as well Jessie is known to with a few dogs become frustrated on leash and bark non stop but with a whats this or this way Jessie she is generally ok. Jessie will really bark if she doesnt like a dog as well.

I have anxiety too and if i were in kays shoes id be ranting on here too scared s***less in hope of some support and not criticism after all we are here to support one another and not judge or anything right?
 

· Banned
Joined
·
5,937 Posts
I also know how hard kay has worked with Tessas reactivity and how she stil works really hard to help Tessa. The fact she even has trainers to help her says alot. I can bet the trainer wouldnt be cheap either. I know the ones on here with reactive dogs work really hard to get it to a manageable level and thats not easy and damn hard work! I know because my brothers dog ozzy is reactive with other dogs to the point we have to let people know he is reactive adn they will go their own way. Otherwise its really not nice what can happen. its due to being in petshop till 5 months old and no proper training and he missed on the important age group to socialise.

I also know first hand due to ozzy how dogs who are reactive get treated by other people tehy think the dog is aggressive etc when they no idea how much work you put into training the dog etc so i admire those of you with reactive dogs on how you put it in all the hard work and effort!
 
  • Like
Reactions: PoppyKenna

· Banned
Joined
·
267 Posts
I can understand the frustration, but as irritating as it might be, I guess when I'm out in a public place, I assume anything could happen.

Seems I'm always comparing dog experiences to horse experiences, but this reminds me of what it's like to take a green or reactive horse to a show. I've had a few of those, and I just have to deal with the fact that some folks don't really give a rip if my horse is going to freak out when they gallop their huge, snorting, flailing Saddlebred right up our rear ends and then past us close enough to nearly side-swipe us. For a horse that has a lot of anxiety about being in "traffic" (as in, a busy arena full of horses being schooled), it's a pretty terrifying situation, especially considering a person can get badly hurt should the horse freak out bad enough to toss his rider, take off, etc. And sometimes I get SO irritated because people should be able to recognize that the horse edgy. I'm always very aware of how the horses in the arena with me are behaving. Their body language is very easy to read, and if one of them looks like it's about to come unglued, I always give it a wide berth (both for that horse and rider's benefit and me and my own horse's).
However, despite my anxiety when put in a situation with less-than-courteous riders, I really cannot blame them. They are there to school and show their horses, and it's not their fault that MY horse is having trouble dealing with the atmosphere. It's not really my horse's fault either, nor is it mine. It just is what it is.

Reactive animals definitely require a lot of patience and confidence from their people.
 

· Super Moderator
Joined
·
3,914 Posts
Sorry, Kay, this really is the never-ending thread. :(

Honestly speaking, all of this "who's to blame?" is really, very pointless. On this festive day, I'd like to just wish Kay well and send her and Tessa a big hug for what was, regardless of who was at fault, an upsetting experience. :huddle:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,661 Posts
This is all just so crazy to me because that is so NORMAL here LOL. I've never thought of it as rude or anything like that. It's a public sidewalk. Oh well. I guess it's at least a heads up to know that you can't always expect people to give wide births or warnings from behind. I know some of the places where I've taken Tigger, there's no way a reactive dog could handle it. People automatically expect your dog to be perfectly fine...You brought it in public, so they assume it's not going to react or bite or lunge at them. If it does, then you get dirty looks from everybody.
I think it comes down to context. In high traffic areas I (and Riley) expect close-quarter meetings/people to zip by since there really isn't space to be as accommodating. I've taken Riley to places like that no problem. He knows there are a lot of people and dogs around and expects to have people come and go regularly. Even then, there's always an etiquette where you stay to the right and respect people's space just to keep the traffic flowing.

However, if I'm walking around the neighborhood where I might see someone maybe once every 5-10 mins then that's a different story. If I'm walking (with or without Riley) and I see a pedestrian I want to pass, and I know they don't know I'm behind them I won't just rush past them. I will give them a wider berth so I don't startle them. The sidewalks are pretty narrow around my neighbourhood so it's not uncommon for walkers/runners/bikers to go onto the grass to loop around pedestrians just to be polite. Some will even go onto the road (it's technically the law for bikes). It's so strange having to explain this, it's just what happens lol

I also want to add, that I don't consider Riley reactive. Hes tried to chase cars maybe twice this year and it's only when he's understimulated/needs exercise. Both times they zoomed past at close proximity (we have no sidewalks on our street) going well over the residential speed limit.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
184 Posts
I really think the problem in this thread is the difference in the culture of various areas. I live in a city on the east coast, and strangers being friendly and courteous is weird here. It just doesn't happen.

If I'm going to walk my dog where I personally live, I fully expect to be passed quickly by joggers. Dog walkers can be slightly more courteous, but on running trails they'll whiz by too even with a dog. Occasionally someone will say "on your left" or something similar, but it's just not the norm. Most people just assume you'd be fine with them passing you close by. My dog is not reactive in these situations so to me it's a non issue.

I think it just sounds strange to some of us because this behavior is very normal in some areas. It must not be in others, thats all.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,004 Posts
@Eenypup - I think you're right.

To me, it doesn't really matter that Kay was walking a reactive dog. Even if she had been alone, being passed like that would have been startling.

It's different if you're in an area where you expect lots of traffic, or if it's daytime and you can see them coming, or even if they're just calmly walking. When I'm out on a walk and see a runner (dog or no dog) I move off to the side to let them through. That seems polite to me. Being passed in close quarters, in the dark, by a runner you didn't know was there....that would scare the daylights out of me, dog or no dog.

Anyway, I know cultures are different - some of my close friends went on a vacation out to LA and they said they had multiple people comment that they weren't from around the area based on the fact that they smiled and said thank you. I've experienced similar situations myself.


I'm glad you're recovering from it, @KayWilson and sorry your thread got so off track! Have a happy new year.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,033 Posts
I really think the problem in this thread is the difference in the culture of various areas. I live in a city on the east coast, and strangers being friendly and courteous is weird here. It just doesn't happen.
I guess what I'm struggling to express is that I don't think it's necessarily discourteous to pass someone from behind on a public sidewalk?
 
21 - 40 of 47 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top