Dog Forum banner

Can't figure out this behavior . . .

862 Views 14 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  JoanneF
I have a 6 year old female German Shepherd - normal in almost every way - except this occasional funky behavior that she's had since about age of 3 to the present. I don't see it as a problem, it's just a curiosity thing for me. She's been eating out of the same shiny, aluminum bowl about 8 inches diameter by 3 inches deep since she was a puppy. The bowl is cleaned after every meal. Her food has no unusual odor. It's always served at room temperature. We feed her the same food every day, twice a day (well, it was the same each day until Royal Canin decided to stop making wet food). Then we switched to Purina One. No "aha!" here though b/c she's had this same behavior before the brand switch as she did (and still does) after the switch. This is the behavior . . . roughly every couple of months and occurring daily for a week or so, she would approach her bowl, stick her nose in, pull it out, move her nose below the bowl, back into the bowl, below the bowl, back into the bowl, above the bowl, back into the bowl, left of the bowl, back in the bowl, to the right of the bowl - all within about 3-4 SECONDS. Of course, the directional sequence is not always the same but you get the picture. If you can visualize such movement in a 3-4 second time frame it's quite a sight to behold. I mean, I've never seen anything like it and I'm 60 years old and have had dogs all my life. She usually eats the food eventually though she has been known to skip a meal here and there, especially when she's in heat. She seems reasonably healthy though and sees the vet, usually twice a year. Because this doesn't seem to be a health issue, it hasn't crossed my mind to mention it during her health checkups though - I really should write it down as something to ask him next time she has a visit.

Anyway, what else could possibly be pertinent . . . she has a younger brother, also a German Shepherd who is one and a half years old. They eat in the same room and at the same time each day but they're separated by a short fence (so there's no competition for the food) and neither has ever jumped the fence. Their bowls are about 8 feet apart. Both dogs are fed the same thing in the same amounts at each meal. The mealtimes are fairly consistent - about every 12 hours. There are no other animals present while they eat. The room in which they eat is indoors and there are no bugs flying around. Ahhh, and the behavior occurs whether I feed them with light in the room or whether she's in near total darkness - so I don't think she's scared of any reflections she may see in her shiny bowl. I haven't fed her from a plastic bowl because I don't see this as a big problem. Again, just a curiosity question. So, any idea why she would behave this way at times?
See less See more
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
I have a 6 year old female German Shepherd - normal in almost every way - except this occasional funky behavior that she's had since about age of 3 to the present. I don't see it as a problem, it's just a curiosity thing for me. She's been eating out of the same shiny, aluminum bowl about 8 inches diameter by 3 inches deep since she was a puppy. The bowl is cleaned after every meal. Her food has no unusual odor. It's always served at room temperature. We feed her the same food every day, twice a day (well, it was the same each day until Royal Canin decided to stop making wet food). Then we switched to Purina One. No "aha!" here though b/c she's had this same behavior before the brand switch as she did (and still does) after the switch. This is the behavior . . . roughly every couple of months and occurring daily for a week or so, she would approach her bowl, stick her nose in, pull it out, move her nose below the bowl, back into the bowl, below the bowl, back into the bowl, above the bowl, back into the bowl, left of the bowl, back in the bowl, to the right of the bowl - all within about 3-4 SECONDS. Of course, the directional sequence is not always the same but you get the picture. If you can visualize such movement in a 3-4 second time frame it's quite a sight to behold. I mean, I've never seen anything like it and I'm 60 years old and have had dogs all my life. She usually eats the food eventually though she has been known to skip a meal here and there, especially when she's in heat. She seems reasonably healthy though and sees the vet, usually twice a year. Because this doesn't seem to be a health issue, it hasn't crossed my mind to mention it during her health checkups though - I really should write it down as something to ask him next time she has a visit.

Anyway, what else could possibly be pertinent . . . she has a younger brother, also a German Shepherd who is one and a half years old. They eat in the same room and at the same time each day but they're separated by a short fence (so there's no competition for the food) and neither has ever jumped the fence. Their bowls are about 8 feet apart. Both dogs are fed the same thing in the same amounts at each meal. The mealtimes are fairly consistent - about every 12 hours. There are no other animals present while they eat. The room in which they eat is indoors and there are no bugs flying around. Ahhh, and the behavior occurs whether I feed them with light in the room or whether she's in near total darkness - so I don't think she's scared of any reflections she may see in her shiny bowl. I haven't fed her from a plastic bowl because I don't see this as a big problem. Again, just a curiosity question. So, any idea why she would behave this way at times?
Have you tried a different bowl? For example a ceramic one?

Also, do you have the bowl in a stand? (Just with you mentioning that she sniffs below the bowl).
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Maybe looking/hoping for something better than what's in the bowl??????????
If it happens at a consistent time of year and the bowl is always in the same place, perhaps the light reflects strangely off the metal or something else nearby. My only other guess would be a discrepancy in the temperature of the food relative to ambient where her bowl is placed, especially if you keep her food stored somewhere like an unheated porch.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Is it a burying behavior? It sounds kind of like a 'burying-with-the-nose' action the way you describe it, but I might be picturing it wrong. My childhood dog would often try to 'bury' food, especially treats, with her nose, in a kind of scooping motion. This could actually work if the treat was given on a blanket, or at the beach in the sand, but I've seen dogs do it when there's nothing to cover the food or bowl with.
Can you post a short video showing the behavior? I understand what happens from your description but it's hard for me to picture all that in 3-4 seconds. I'm curious to see how fast this doggy's head is moving.
From Iheartdogs:
"Aluminum is not commonly used in dog bowls, and for good reason – aluminum can leach into food and cause cognitive dysfunction and bone damage. If aluminum is used in pots and pans for human use, it's supposed to be anodized. "

I would switch to either ceramic (per @LMMB), or stainless steel for dog dishes...next I would find a better food than Purina One, which is marginal at best.
I use this site for finding out about dog foods and they give unbiased reviews.


You can do a lot better for your dog, for the same $$.
  • Like
Reactions: 3
You can do a lot better for your dog, for the same $$.
This reminds me, is there a comprehensive thread on various popular dog food brands here? I know a little from working with vets and trainers (back when we had a cat we typically fed it Science Diet which seemed reasonably high quality without being crazy expensive) but I'd bet many folks here have looked much further into it.
I don't think there is, partly because it's quite subjective (what suits my dog might not suit yours) and partly because dogfoodadviser is so comprehensive.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
This reminds me, is there a comprehensive thread on various popular dog food brands here? I know a little from working with vets and trainers (back when we had a cat we typically fed it Science Diet which seemed reasonably high quality without being crazy expensive) but I'd bet many folks here have looked much further into it.
I suggest researching the 4 star foods (and up) on dogfoodadvisor.com. As @JoanneF said, we all have different criteria. I will also recommend Costco Kirkland Chicken and Rice KIBBLE, having fed it for over 25 yrs, until the pandemic caused a huge spike in the price and I go through 40+lbs of dog food a month (3 medium and large dogs)

The above is made by Diamond Foods that has a very similar ingredient list as their Diamond Naturals Chicken and Rice branded food. BTW: It is also a 4-5 star food and, although going up in price, is less money than the Kirkland branded product.


I am not a fan of wet foods, unless a little is needed to entice a picky eater. In that case you can spike the kibble with sardines in WATER, or some stinky cheese. I also feed some raw turkey roll in addition to raw chicken weekly.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Is there any chance that she just dose not want the amount that you are offering her. Have you tried feeding her less until she decides that she is really hungry or maybe just one meal a day. A mature lady of her age may not require so much food and this is her way of cutting back on her amount. 😕
I have a 6 year old female German Shepherd - normal in almost every way - except this occasional funky behavior that she's had since about age of 3 to the present. I don't see it as a problem, it's just a curiosity thing for me. She's been eating out of the same shiny, aluminum bowl about 8 inches diameter by 3 inches deep since she was a puppy. The bowl is cleaned after every meal. Her food has no unusual odor. It's always served at room temperature. We feed her the same food every day, twice a day (well, it was the same each day until Royal Canin decided to stop making wet food). Then we switched to Purina One. No "aha!" here though b/c she's had this same behavior before the brand switch as she did (and still does) after the switch. This is the behavior . . . roughly every couple of months and occurring daily for a week or so, she would approach her bowl, stick her nose in, pull it out, move her nose below the bowl, back into the bowl, below the bowl, back into the bowl, above the bowl, back into the bowl, left of the bowl, back in the bowl, to the right of the bowl - all within about 3-4 SECONDS. Of course, the directional sequence is not always the same but you get the picture. If you can visualize such movement in a 3-4 second time frame it's quite a sight to behold. I mean, I've never seen anything like it and I'm 60 years old and have had dogs all my life. She usually eats the food eventually though she has been known to skip a meal here and there, especially when she's in heat. She seems reasonably healthy though and sees the vet, usually twice a year. Because this doesn't seem to be a health issue, it hasn't crossed my mind to mention it during her health checkups though - I really should write it down as something to ask him next time she has a visit.

Anyway, what else could possibly be pertinent . . . she has a younger brother, also a German Shepherd who is one and a half years old. They eat in the same room and at the same time each day but they're separated by a short fence (so there's no competition for the food) and neither has ever jumped the fence. Their bowls are about 8 feet apart. Both dogs are fed the same thing in the same amounts at each meal. The mealtimes are fairly consistent - about every 12 hours. There are no other animals present while they eat. The room in which they eat is indoors and there are no bugs flying around. Ahhh, and the behavior occurs whether I feed them with light in the room or whether she's in near total darkness - so I don't think she's scared of any reflections she may see in her shiny bowl. I haven't fed her from a plastic bowl because I don't see this as a big problem. Again, just a curiosity question. So, any idea why she would behave this way at times?
I had to switch my stainless bowls out for porcelain because of static electricity in the air that would shock my dogs when they tried to eat. Could that be the problem?
  • Wow
Reactions: 1
I had to switch my stainless bowls out for porcelain because of static electricity in the air that would shock my dogs when they tried to eat. Could that be the problem?
I'm surprised static electricity would be such a problem...do you live in an area with lots of lightning? Generally if there's a shock it's from stray current - though even that is usually only a problem with livestock (what with galvanized water tanks and electrical fencing...)
I'm surprised static electricity would be such a problem...do you live in an area with lots of lightning? Generally if there's a shock it's from stray current - though even that is usually only a problem with livestock (what with galvanized water tanks and electical fencing...)
We do get some lightning during the spring and summer but any humidity will cause it. I just found that the stainless was shocking my dogs when they were trying to eat and they literally stopped eating, so I switched them out to porcelain and no more problems.
  • Wow
Reactions: 1
Years ago I remember getting static electricity shocks from carpet with a high nylon content, I haven't had that for years though. :unsure:
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top