You need to ditch the prong collar and the idea of corrections, respect, being the "alpha" and also the alpha rolling -- now. If you don't, this dog is going to bite you - I promise you that.
What do you mean by "acting dominant"? Are you referring to growling/snapping/lunging?
He sounds reactive. It's either based in overstimulation or fear. Honestly, it doesn't much matter which as the way to handle it is basically the same.
Look into counter conditioning/desensitization and "look at that" (LAT) games. You want him far enough away from the other dog that he doesn't react, but close enough that he notices the other dog. This is his threshold. When he sees another dog, give him tons of delicious treats, when the other dog leaves the treats stop.
Once he seems to catch onto this game, you could move onto behavioral adjustment training (BAT) type stuff - I use a modified version with my dog and have had some success after just a few sessions.
In all honesty, since you are so deeply involved with punishment based training, I think you'd be better off just hiring a positive trainer or behaviorist (there's a sticky on this board that can help find one) to teach you how to better work with your dog.
This will take time. In fact, it will probably take more time since the relationship between you and your dog is already damaged. But it can be done.
The funny thing is, a lot of people who subscribe to the 'alpha' ideal get so hung up on their dog respecting them....your dog will "respect" you much more when he no longer fears you and you can work as cooperative team.
What do you mean by "acting dominant"? Are you referring to growling/snapping/lunging?
He sounds reactive. It's either based in overstimulation or fear. Honestly, it doesn't much matter which as the way to handle it is basically the same.
Look into counter conditioning/desensitization and "look at that" (LAT) games. You want him far enough away from the other dog that he doesn't react, but close enough that he notices the other dog. This is his threshold. When he sees another dog, give him tons of delicious treats, when the other dog leaves the treats stop.
Once he seems to catch onto this game, you could move onto behavioral adjustment training (BAT) type stuff - I use a modified version with my dog and have had some success after just a few sessions.
In all honesty, since you are so deeply involved with punishment based training, I think you'd be better off just hiring a positive trainer or behaviorist (there's a sticky on this board that can help find one) to teach you how to better work with your dog.
This will take time. In fact, it will probably take more time since the relationship between you and your dog is already damaged. But it can be done.
The funny thing is, a lot of people who subscribe to the 'alpha' ideal get so hung up on their dog respecting them....your dog will "respect" you much more when he no longer fears you and you can work as cooperative team.