No No.. not at all.... That is how Atka started her lessons.
My point is that even if you are using dog broke trial or training stock, the PREMISE is the same. The stock is more important than the dog. Things like gripping in the excitement and prey drive etc. can destroy stock and a dog that does those things is not a herding dog.
Some dogs will grip in the excitement but I have seen GSD's out on stock and they are not herding.. they are hunting and their intent is to do harm. I know of a BC that herds beautifully but grips every run so is no longer herding anything but the handler. He is done, that dog is!
The poiint I am making is the object or herding is that the dog is a tool in handling stock like the tractor is a tool in bringing feed to the stock and taking away the manure. A good dog makes stock handling beautiful and seemingly easy.
The Trial is an extension of herding for real.. on a ranch or farm for a rancher or farmer.. so the dog must still work with the stock being first and foremost.
That is what I mean. Many people go into herding and it is all about the dog.. when they need to remember what this is really about and that is learning how to handle stock with a dog as a tool to that end.
You will have fun but you should find you are learning an awful lot about livestock. IOW's we will make a farmer outta you yet!